Writers on the pain of hindsight in publishing: ‘It’s like a bad breakup – you have to move on’

From The Guardian:

My first book came out a year ago. It wasn’t a bestseller, and it wasn’t intended to be one. In Spite of Oceans: Migrant Voices is a quiet book of short stories based on real, everyday family lives. The stories are about how people deal with the messy stuff life throws at them; about relationships coming together, or unfolding, or crumpling under the tension of it all.

Over the course of the last year, I have started to feel out of sorts about the book. Several copies of it lie in my hallway cupboard, next to a box of old doorkeys, unintentionally kept over the years.

The problem is that I have had too much time to think about it – hindsight has got the better of me. I know the book is not awful, because it has been well-received and some objective readers have enjoyed it. But inside I feel it’s not brilliant – it’s not bad, it’s no big deal, it’s just OK. Which isn’t quite good enough. I keep thinking I could have done better, written better. If only this, if only that. Don’t we all feel that way when we’re striving to express something we care about?

They say hindsight is a wonderful thing. As a writer, however, it’s irritating, an itch in an awkward place. Hindsight does no favours for those who are naturally self-deprecating. Even though your work is already published, a writer can never quite draw a line and accept that something is finished. “Resign yourself to the lifelong sadness that comes from never being satisfied,” Zadie Smith wrote in her rules for writers. You self-indulgently edit and edit, tweak and tweak all the time in your head, and it’ll never, ever be perfect.

. . . .

Stephen King wrote: “I have spent a good many years since – too many, I think – being ashamed about what I write.” Self-doubt is heightened by procrastination. This kind of hindsight lodges itself in your mind like a relative who drops in uninvited and then stays far too long. How, then, to say enough is enough? How to tell hindsight to get the hell out? How to move on?

I asked seasoned writers for advice. I have learned that it’s OK to feel weird about your book, and that many writers are at odds with what they have written after it is published. But I also learned that you have to move on, because if you don’t it will consume you. In three words: get over it.

Link to the rest at The Guardian

Courtesy of The Passive Voice.

Bookenfreude

From TeleRead:

I’d like to add a new term to the publishing debate: Bookenfreude. I’m defining this as: “irrational pleasure derived from any apparent misfortune for e-books, regardless of truth, context, or implications.” And I was inspired by Len Epps’s terrific summary of the state of modern publishing in TechCrunch, “On The Dark Matter Of The Publishing Industry.” (Chris Meadows has also covered the piece for TeleRead.) There, he waxes on Matthew Ingram’s evocation of “a whiff of anti-digital Schadenfreude” in his counterblast to the New York Times‘s recent thinly disguised puff piece for Big Publishing on the supposed slump in e-book sales. So I tried to go one better by summing up the whole phenomenon in one word.

Epps doesn’t exactly add much to our understanding of the Trad/Big Pub vs. Self/E-Pub debate, though he does articulate it beautifully. It’s not exactly news to say that traditional publishers are trying to trap the post-e-book world into the same structures and business models that were dictated by paper print publishing. After all, that’s just what Big Media has done in every other digitally disrupted medium so far. However, Epps does highlight how transparently false and self-serving Big Publishing’s arguments have become, even to relatively neutral observers.

Welcome to The Author Society

Welcome to The Author Society, a consortium of like-minded authors who work together for mutual benefit.

This site is used for book discussions, promotion and marketing discussions, collaborations, chit-chat, and anything else needed for the writing, publishing, and marketing of new work. Additionally, the blog portion of The Author Society collates news, images, RSS feeds, and videos related to the publishing and writing industries.

Thank you for stopping by.